'Re-examining Liberation in Namibia: Political Culture Since Independence' edited by Henning Melber

The back cover of Re-examining Liberation in Namibia: Political Culture Since Independence, edited by Henning Melber, asks the question of what Namibian children can expect from their future in ‘the land of the brave’ (as the national anthem proclaims)? This question frames the taking stock of emerging trends in the country’s political culture since independence in 1990 as the contributors critically explore the achievements and shortcomings that have been part of liberation in Namibia.

Dealing with a wide array of subjects relevant to recent history in Namibia, the collection weaves together a rich tapestry of diverse subjects. It succeeds in pulling together a picture of the sometimes schizophrenic liberation movement SWAPO, which led resistance to colonial rule from 1960, in terms of its worthy values and ambitions compared to the reality of a liberation movement in power.

The themes of this collection illuminate not only the challenges facing present-day Namibia but also resonate throughout the Southern African region. Issues related to land and indigenous people crop up frequently, as does that of truth and reconciliation, memory and forgetting.

Perhaps the contrast between liberation in action and the present day reality is best captured in the fascinating deconstruction of President Sam Nujoma’s personality in an essay by Christopher Saunders entitled ‘Liberation and Democracy: A critical reading of Sam Nujoma’s Autobiography’. This paints a picture of a heroic and committed Sam Nujoma as he travelled through the airports of the world gathering support for his just cause as a young man with little experience of politics. But this contrasts with Nujoma’s highly selective and sometimes inaccurate version of events in relation to the liberation struggle, so that Saunders concludes that “Nujoma’s work is more a work of propaganda than of history”. “It conforms that the liberation struggle was fought for national liberation, and that this meant, for Nujoma and others, the accession of Swapo to power.”

The attempt by Swapo and Nujoma to remember the past in a certain way, to construct it and stamp it on the nation’s consciousness, is also raised in an excellent essay by John Saul and Colin Leys entitled ‘Truth, Reconciliation, Amnesia: The “ex-detainees” fight for Justice’. Here the issue of missing Swapo activists allegedly killed at the hands of their own organisation is carefully examined in the context of the liberation movement’s inclination to bury historical record with the excuse that opening up old wounds would be harmful to national reconciliation efforts. This is contrasted strongly with efforts by those in Namibian society who believe that actively remembering the past will open up the path to a more meaningful reconciliation.

How is the past remembered and who has the right to remember it? Who has control over the nation’s consciousness? What is national interest and in whose interest does it operate? How do we go about understanding the sometimes contradictory and authoritarian nature of liberation movements? How do these liberation movements understand democracy? These are just some of the questions that Re-examining Liberation in Namibia touches on, and together with many others, the collection provides a critical understanding of Namibian politics and its current day state of health.
(ISBN 91-7106-516-4)

Reviewed by Patrick Burnett, Fahamu